March 02, 2019

Oakland Teachers: The Deal Stinks – Vote It Down!

Escalate the Strike By Taking It to the Port

Oakland Teachers:
The Deal Stinks – Vote It Down!
No Cuts, No Layoffs, No School Closures!

By Class Struggle Education Workers

Jeff Chiu / AP
Teachers, staff, parents, students and supporters at OEA rally at Oakland City Hall on the first day of the strike, Feb. 21.
 After a week on the picket lines in a rock-solid strike, on Friday the leadership of the Oakland Education Association (OEA) announced a rotten deal which sells short the demands that teachers have been fighting for. Even before the tentative agreement had gone up on the Internet so members could read it, officials ordered strike pickets taken down, contrary to the decision of the Rep Council on Thursday to keep strike lines up until the membership voted. 


As the press conference announcing the agreement was live on the OEA Facebook page there were lots of comments posted opposed to it (try finding them now). At a meeting of the Rep Council today (Saturday, March 2) many activists voiced opposition. Remember: the membership IS the union, and this deal does not at all reflect what the membership voted to strike for. The tentative agreement includes:

  • A salary agreement that is really a pay cut. The tentative deal is for 11% over four years, or 2.75% per year. The rate of inflation last year in the Bay Area according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics was 3.9%. The average increase in Oakland apartment rents last year was 12.7%. As for the 3% signing bonus (bribe), the cost of living for Bay Area residents has already risen over 6% in the year and a half that Oakland teachers have been working without a contract. Do the math.
  •  Minimal cuts in class size. Class sizes will be cut by one (1) student in the coming year for “highest- needs” schools, and one (1) student for all schools in the following year. The difference between teaching a class of 30 vs. 32 students will be practically unnoticeable.
  • Nothing to stop school closures. The “5 month pause” on new school closures is no win at all – in fact, it may aid the OUSD in closing schools. It means that Roots Academy would still be closed, and the School Board can order the other 23 schools on its chopping block closed during the summer recess when teachers are not there and parents are not mobilized. 
  • Nothing to stop charter schools. Getting the pro-charter School Board to send a hypocritical letter to state authorities calling for a temporary moratorium on new charters will achieve zero.
  •  No real increase in student support. No additional nurses, reduction of counselor caseload from 600:1 to 550:1? This won’t be “the schools our students deserve,” as the OEA rightly called for.
  •  Plus any gains will be paid for by cutting programs and laying off staff. The OUSD has already announced $30 million in cuts, including laying off as many as 150 classified staff represented by the SEIU and AFSCME. This deal is stabbing them in the back. 

This tentative agreement is an insult to the educators who undertook months of preparations for this strike and a slap in the face for the students and parents who joined the picket lines and marches. Class Struggle Education Workers urges Oakland teachers on Sunday to VOTE “NO” ON THE TENTATIVE AGREEMENT.

Photo courtesy of Daphne Crane
Oakland School Board member Jumoke Hinton-Hodge,
right, choking kindergarten teacher and OEA strike
captain Darnisha Wright while trying to cross a picket
line at La Escuelita Elementary School, March 1.
Overturning a rotten contract negotiated by the union leadership is a big deal. The House of Delegates of the Chicago Teachers Union did it in 2012, whereupon the leadership (of the Caucus of Rank-and-file Educators, or CORE) turned around and shoved the deal down the delegates’ throat in a second vote. To be successful it is necessary to have a clear and simple message.

The rotten deal is the product of the union bureaucracy (yes, the OEA has one, we’re seeing it in action right now) that seeks to balance between the employers and the union ranks, acting as an obstacle to militant class struggle. 


In going back to the bargaining table, in order to ensure rank-and-file control, negotiations and strike activity should be under an ELECTED STRIKE COMMITTEE.


Bottom-line strike demands should be: NO CUTS – NO LAYOFFS – NO SCHOOL CLOSURES! 


And to escalate the pressure on the District, TAKE OEA PICKET LINES TO THE PORT OF OAKLAND where ILWU Local 34 has voted to support the teachers strike and the ILWU Local 10 membership meeting enthusiastically applauded OEA leaders on the first day of the strike.


Class Struggle Education Workers has called for union action to shut down the port in solidarity with the teachers strike (see our leaflet, “Mobilize Bay Area Workers to Win Oakland Teachers Strike” on the CSEW site). CSEW supporters in Oakland advocated this in meetings with strike activists this past week. So have others. This deal, if approved, would short-circuit the decision of the Rep Council to mass picket at the port next week. 


A mass outpouring of striking teachers and supporters together with dock workers at the port where the profits of Bay Area rulers are generated could be key to winning a real victory.


The battle to defend public education against the capitalist privatizers and their charter schools must be fought politically. Ultimately it must be taken to Sacramento, not to lobby hat-in-hand but to occupy and shut it down, as teachers from West Virginia to Arizona did against Republican governments last year. That means mobilizing teachers throughout the state, but above all, in deep-blue California, to be successful it requires a SHARP BREAK WITH THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY, the bosses’ party that is centrally responsible for the education crisis facing us today.

Class Struggle Education Workers (CSEW) is part of the fight for a revitalization and transformation of the labor movement into an instrument for the emancipation of the working class and the oppressed See the CSEW program here.

Transport Workers and ILWU on first day of Oakland teachers strike, February 21. (Internationalist photo)